My mother stood at the kitchen counter one afternoon and refused to say sorry. I was maybe nine. I remember the linoleum, the yellow light through the window over the sink, and the particular way her jaw set. My father stood three feet away, waiting. Neither of them moved. The silence went on so long that I could hear the refrigerator humming, and I remember looking down at their legs, at their locked, rigid knees, and thinking: they look like trees.
Trees. Standing in the kitchen, absolutely certain they were right.
I didn't have words for it then. I only knew that something in my chest tightened when I watched two people I loved hold their ground so fiercely that the ground became the whole point. Decades later, after thirty years of sitting with bodies, with the stories bodies keep and the messages they send, I understand what I was seeing. I was watching the body tell the truth about the heart.
Because here's the thing about knees. They're built to bend. That's their whole purpose, their sacred job. They absorb the shock of every step you take, carrying you through the world with a kind of quiet generosity. And when they stop bending, when they stiffen and ache and refuse, I've come to believe they're often speaking about something much older than cartilage.
What the Knees Are Trying to Tell You
Let me say something plainly: I don't believe your body is your enemy. Not ever. Every symptom, every ache, every stubborn stiffness is a communication, a message in the only language the body has, which is sensation. The body is a sacred messenger. It doesn't lie, and it doesn't flatter, and it doesn't wait for you to be ready.
In the traditions I've studied over the years, the knees hold a particular wisdom. They're the joints of humility, of flexibility, of the capacity to bow. Think of how we kneel in prayer, in proposal, in grief, in gratitude. Think of the phrase "bring someone to their knees." Our language already knows. We've always understood, somewhere beneath thought, that the knee is where we yield.
And yielding is a tricky business, being human.
When someone comes to me with knee pain, I never begin with a theory. I begin with a question, offered gently: where in your life are you holding so firmly that nothing can move through you? Sometimes the answer arrives instantly, with tears. A sister they haven't spoken to in eleven years. A boss they've silently resented. A parent they've never forgiven. Sometimes the answer takes weeks to surface, rising slowly like something coming up from deep water. Both are perfect.
I want to be careful here, because I've seen this kind of wisdom get twisted into blame. Please hear me: you did not cause your knee pain by being stubborn. Bodies are complicated, and injuries happen, and bones wear down for all kinds of reasons that have nothing to do with your character. Honor the medical care you need. Take the physical seriously. But also, perhaps, let the body's message be an invitation rather than a verdict. What if the stiffness is simply asking you to notice something? What if it's not punishing you at all, only tapping you on the shoulder?
Stubbornness, after all, isn't a flaw. It's a protection. Somewhere along the way, it kept you safe.
The Brain That Learned to Hold On
I find it endlessly fascinating that the nervous system has its own version of what the knees are showing us. When you dig in your heels, as we say, there's a real neurological process underway. Your brain has learned that yielding is dangerous, and it has built a pathway to make sure you never do it again.
Here's a very good thing to know: every time you've defended a position, protected your pride, or refused to bend, you've strengthened a neural pathway. Neurons that fire together wire together, as the old saying in neuroscience goes. Repeat a response often enough, and it becomes a groove, a well-worn riverbed your energy flows down automatically. You don't decide to be stubborn in that moment. The groove decides for you.
And the groove usually began early. Maybe you grew up in a home where saying sorry meant losing, where apologies were weapons, where the person who bent first was the person who got steamrolled. Maybe you learned that your needs only mattered if you held them tightly. Maybe, like my mother at that kitchen counter, you inherited a posture along with a surname. A way of standing in the world that your grandmother stood in, and her mother before her.
I think about this often, how we carry our lineage in our joints. In my book, Elevating Your Origins to Love, I write about how the patterns we think of as ours are so often inherited, handed down through the family line like silverware. The rigid knee isn't only yours. It may belong to a long line of people who survived by not bending. People who lived through wars and poverty and loss, who learned that giving an inch meant losing the farm, the family, the future. Their stubbornness was courage - it was survival. It got you here.
Can you feel that? How much love might be hidden inside the very thing you've judged yourself for?
Now, the nervous system has a few other tricks worth knowing about. When we feel threatened, whether the threat is real or only remembered, the amygdala fires and the body prepares to defend. Muscles tighten. The jaw sets, just like my mother's. Can you feel that? The hips and thighs brace - the knees lock. You might notice that the old fight response, running quietly beneath the surface of an ordinary argument over who forgot to take out the garbage. Your body doesn't know the difference between a saber-toothed tiger and your husband's offhand comment about the dishes. It simply protects.
The beautiful news is that the brain remains plastic throughout your whole life. The groove can soften. New pathways can form, and the old ones, through lack of use, gradually prune away. It doesn't happen through force, though. You can't bully yourself into flexibility. Trust me, I've tried. The pathway to yielding is built the way all lasting change is built: gently, repeatedly, with a great deal of kindness toward the part of you that's afraid.
The Courage Hidden in Yielding
Let me tell you about the first time I truly understood what it meant to bend.
Years ago, I was in a long, quiet conflict with someone I loved deeply. I won't say who. The details don't matter, and honestly, they're not mine alone to tell. What matters is that I was right. I was so certain I was right that I could have drawn you a diagram. I'd rehearsed my case in the shower, on walks, in the dead hours of the night. And I noticed, during that season, that my right knee had begun to ache. Not dramatically. Just a low, persistent complaint every time I climbed the stairs.
I ignored it for months, which is what we do.
Then one morning in meditation, I found myself resting my attention on that knee. Not trying to fix it. Seriously, right? Just keeping it company, the way you'd sit beside a friend who's having a hard day. And slowly, an image rose: me, standing very straight, arms crossed, in a doorway I refused to walk through. The knee, in that moment, felt like a door hinge rusted shut.
I laughed, actually. Out loud, alone on my cushion. Because the message was so obvious it was almost funny. My body had been waving a flag for months, and I'd been too busy being right to read it.
Here's what gets me, still. When I finally picked up the phone and said what I needed to say, it wasn't a surrender. I'd always imagined yielding as collapse, as losing, as the thing that happens when you've been defeated. What I felt instead was spaciousness. A loosening behind my ribs. The conversation wasn't tidy, and I didn't get everything I wanted. But something opened, and for the first time in months I took a full breath all the way down into my belly.
The knee eased within the week. I won't claim cause and effect, because the body is far too mysterious for tidy equations. But I will say that I walked up those stairs differently, afterward.
I've come to believe that yielding is one of the bravest things a human being can do. It asks you to let your armor down while the world is still watching. It asks you to risk being hurt, misunderstood, taken advantage of. And yet it's the only door that leads to genuine intimacy, because you cannot be close to someone you're braced against. Closeness requires that the knees soften.
The Tao te Ching, which I've returned to for most of my adult life, says it better than I can: the supple willow survives the storm that snaps the rigid oak. Water, the softest thing in the world, wears away the hardest stone. There's an entire philosophy folded into that image. Strength isn't the refusal to move. Strength is the capacity to move without breaking.
Sit with that for a moment.
An Invitation to Soften
If any of this stirs something in you, here's a gentle practice. It's an invitation, not an assignment, so take what serves you and leave the rest.
Find a quiet place and sit comfortably, feet on the floor. Rest your hands on your knees. Just let them rest there, warm and steady, as if you were greeting an old friend. Take a few slow breaths, and let your attention drift down into the joints themselves. What do they feel like? Tight? Tender? Numb? Warm? There's no right answer. You're simply listening.
Then, softly, ask: what are you holding for me?
And wait - don't force a response. Let the body speak in its own time, in its own language, which may come as an image, a memory, a name, a color, or nothing at all. If nothing arrives, that's perfectly fine. The asking itself is a kind of bow. It tells your nervous system that you're finally willing to listen, and that alone begins to change the conversation.
If a person comes to mind, someone you've been braced against, you might simply notice what it would be like to bend toward them in your imagination. Not to excuse anything, not to pretend the hurt wasn't real, only to feel what happens in your body when you picture yourself softening. Do your shoulders drop? - does your breath deepen? Or does something in you resist, loudly? Either response is information. Either is welcome.
Sometimes the stubbornness isn't about another person at all. Sometimes it's the part of you that refuses to rest, refuses to receive help, refuses to admit you're tired. If you're someone who carries everything, who never asks, who can't remember the last time you let anyone carry you, your knees may be asking for something quite different. They may be asking you to kneel, not in defeat, but in rest. To let yourself be held.
I think about how often we confuse stiffness with strength, and how much it costs us. And I think about the grief that sometimes lives under the stubbornness, the old wounds that said never again, never bend, never let them see you weak. That grief deserves tenderness. It was only ever trying to protect you.
There's another kind of healing that can happen here, one that echoes what I explore in crystallized emotions held in the kidneys: the idea that unexpressed feeling doesn't vanish, it settles into the body and waits. Pride and fear and old resentment can harden in the joints the same way. And just as with any held emotion, the softening begins when you stop fighting it and start befriending it.
I think of my mother again, standing at that counter. I didn't understand then that she was afraid. That under all that rigid certainty was a little girl who'd learned that bending meant being hurt. I wish I could go back and put my small hand in hers and tell her: you can soften, love. The ground will hold you.
Years later, in her last season, she did soften. She said things to me I'd waited my whole life to hear. And I watched her knees, her old, arthritic, hard-working knees, ease into the chair as though they'd finally been given permission to rest.
Maybe that's the deepest gift of yielding. It gives everyone around you permission, too.
So may your knees remember what they were made for. May you find the courage to bow when bowing is truth, and the wisdom to stand when standing is love. May the places you've held so tightly begin, gently, to breathe. And may you know, beloved one, that you were never weak for bending. You were only ever becoming water.
With love, Susan





